Finally posting this after weeks of going back and forth on my own.
The marketing vs reality gap on most of these platforms is enormous. Success stories in ads are almost never representative.
Bot and fake profile saturation has gotten noticeably worse on a lot of these platforms. Even paid tiers aren't immune to it.
Negative experiences are just as useful as positive ones, so don't hold back.
One that I've been seeing pop up recently is Flurrydate — has anyone here used it?