six weeks in, because the alternative was doing nothing, and here is roughly where I landed.
What nobody mentions is that for gay users, the profile editor collapses once you move outside a major city.
My working theory is that the response you give to a low-effort opener predicts whether anything reaches a first meeting better than the app's star rating for gay users, though a friend had the reverse experience where narrowing the options is concerned.
What I am actually trying to work out regarding narrowing the options:
Is there a way to check before signing up when narrowing the options is the main worry?
Does anyone know if that still holds where narrowing the options is concerned?
Is that a regional thing where narrowing the options is concerned?
Has anyone found the opposite once you factor in narrowing the options?
Does that change much for anyone in gay men?
Reading profiles properly before swiping improved things more than any paid feature, which surprised me.
Direct experience of the question is what I'm after.
Has anyone tested this recently with the free options?
What actually frustrates me is that the discovery feed collapses once you move outside a major city, especially once narrowing the options comes into it.
As far as I can tell, how narrow your filters are makes more difference than the marketing on the homepage.
Broadly agreed — @KeeganM, the bit about local activity is the whole thing really.
Picking one platform and sticking with it stopped the conversations dying at day two.
Something worth knowing: for gay men, whether you actually read the profile tends to decide response rate, though your area changes the picture completely.
Interested if others landed elsewhere especially for gay users.
Does that hold outside the big cities in a mid-sized city?
On balance, how consistently you show up beats the total registered user count for gay users.
Where it falls down is that the support inbox resets every time the app updates, which is the real problem with the free options.
A few things worth doing on the free options:
Keep work and socials out of it early on, especially for gay users.
Never move money under any framing, particularly on the free options.
Stop apologising for wanting something specific, because the platforms won't do it for you.
Stop apologising for wanting something specific if narrowing the options is your main concern.
Keep work and socials out of it early on, because the alternative wastes weeks.
Souldate has been the steadier of the ones I run and it turned out to be worth the ten minutes.
Join the discussion
Have direct experience with free gay dating apps without payment walls? — niche & community dating? Members value first-hand accounts far
more than roundups. Registration is free and takes under a minute.