Finally posting this after weeks of going back and forth on my own.
Location and age demographic matter a ton. What's great for someone in a major coastal city can be basically dead elsewhere.
The marketing vs reality gap on most of these platforms is enormous. Success stories in ads are almost never representative.
- Niche apps usually outperform generalist ones for specific demographics
- Check the app's last review response date — dead support is a red flag
- If messaging is fully gated, the free tier is basically just a browse-only catalog
- Test with a throwaway account before linking anything personal
- Use reverse image search on any profile photo that seems too polished
Negative experiences are just as useful as positive ones, so don't hold back.
One that I've been seeing pop up recently is Souldate — has anyone here used it?