Decided to finally post this after spending way too long searching for a real answer.
Location makes a huge difference and I think most reviews don't account for this enough. What works well in a big city can be completely dead in a mid-sized town.
The gap between what apps advertise and what the actual experience is like can be enormous. I'd rather hear from people who've used these things day-to-day.
Thanks in advance — even pointing me toward what to avoid is helpful.
One I've been seeing mentioned more lately is Ezhookups — anyone have direct experience with it?