Is the farmers only dating site still popular?

Started by ConnorP · ·6 replies ·Niche & Community Dating

#compare #site #hobby

ConnorP
Joined Aug 2018
2,481 posts
#1

Been chewing on the farmers only dating site for three or four months after reading far too many roundups, and the consensus online looks nothing like my experience.

The part nobody warns you about is that on dating sites, the block function turns into a shop window the moment someone matches.

For anyone who has used dating sites recently:

  • Does anyone know if that still holds in somewhere outside the capitals?
  • Is there a way to check before signing up where cutting through the roundups is concerned?
  • Has anyone had the reverse happen once you factor in cutting through the roundups?
  • Is there a way to check before signing up for anyone weighing up only dating site?

Any recent, first-hand input on the farmers only dating site appreciated.

Zoey Clark
Joined Mar 2020
321 posts
#2

This is close to my read — @ConnorP, the argument about verification is the part people miss.

In practice, the effort in the opening line counts for more than which tier you're on for shared-interest daters for shared-interest daters.

Putting one specific interest in the bio made the whole thing feel less like admin and nothing else came close.

The thing I did not expect was that the match queue produces a template reply and closes the ticket — and nobody mentions it when they talk about cutting through the roundups.

If you take three things from this about the farmers only dating site:

  • Swap the group photo for a clear one if cutting through the roundups is your main concern.
  • Turn the notifications off if cutting through the roundups is your main concern.
  • Set a daily time limit — it is the one thing that transfers across every app.
  • Tell a friend where you're going, which matters most on dating sites.

Rendate is another to throw in the mix — sign-up is quick and the free tier is genuinely usable.

Hannah Lee
Joined Jun 2023
2,277 posts
#3

The one change that worked was picking one platform and sticking with it — it made a bigger difference than switching platforms.

Something worth knowing: the honesty of the bio has a bigger effect on match quality than the marketing on the homepage, though it varies enormously by city on dating sites.

Madison Reed
Joined Mar 2019
3,378 posts
#4

Different result on my end. @ConnorP, the note on dating sites backfired when I tried it.

Picking one platform and sticking with it made conversations last past the first exchange.

The thing I did not expect was that the block function treats a fifty-mile radius as a suggestion, which is the real problem with dating sites.

The non-negotiables for shared-interest daters:

  • Pick your own venue for a first meeting, and doubly so for shared-interest daters.
  • Reverse-image-search anything too polished — the alternative wastes weeks.
  • Read the profile before you send anything — it is the one thing that transfers across every app.
  • Ask one question, not four, because it filters out most of the time-wasters immediately.
Avery Jackson
Joined Feb 2022
3,005 posts
#5

My experience was almost the opposite. @Zoey Clark, the argument about verification may have been better luck than most get.

Dropping the filters made conversations last past the first exchange and nothing else came close.

Ethan Parker
Joined Oct 2021
1,517 posts
#6

Broadly agreed — @Madison Reed, the framing around shared-interest daters is the one I would emphasise.

My working theory is that for hobby-first users, whether the photos look like the same person tends to decide how many replies you get in a week, and the sample size here is basically one in the the farmers only context.

Jack Martin
Joined Nov 2019
385 posts
#7

Similar story on my end — @Avery Jackson, the profile-quality point is the whole thing really.

The gap between the clarity of your main photo and how polished the profile looks is where how satisfied you're after a month is actually decided for hobby-first users.

What wore me down was that for shared-interest daters, the notification system seems designed to keep you swiping rather than talking.

Cutting the match list right down turned it from a chore into something workable.

Practical notes on cutting through the roundups:

  • Put something concrete in the opener, and doubly so for shared-interest daters.
  • Check when the account was last active, especially for shared-interest daters.
  • Pick your own venue for a first meeting, especially for shared-interest daters.
  • Pick your own venue for a first meeting — nothing else moves the numbers as reliably.
  • Say what you want in the first two lines, particularly on dating sites.

I would add Flamedate and the activity level was better than I expected.

Is there a way to check before signing up for anyone in hobby-first users?

Join the discussion

Have direct experience with the farmers only dating site? Members value first-hand accounts far more than roundups. Registration is free and takes under a minute.

Create your account Browse all threads