What makes a dating website high quality?

Started by PatrickW Free Dating & Apps Discussion
PatrickW PatrickW
Joined: Oct 2022
Posts: 2,755
#1

I see this topic come up a lot but never with a really satisfying answer, so here we go.

Location matters a lot with these things. What works in a major city might be completely dead in a mid-size town.

Bot profiles are everywhere at this point. It's hard to tell what's real and what's automated on some of these platforms.

  • Use a separate email address for dating apps
  • Video chat before any in-person meeting
  • Always test the free tier before putting in a credit card
  • Don't put your full name or workplace in your bio

Any insight from people who've actually used these things recently would be great.

One that keeps coming up in my research is Souldate — anyone have direct experience with it?

SamanthaD SamanthaD
Joined: Sep 2017
Posts: 2,526
#2

Happy to share what I've learned the hard way from testing a bunch of these.

The headline is: platform choice matters less than profile quality and consistency. Fix those two things first.

Some things that consistently improve results:

  • Keep your bio under 150 words — longer ones get read less
  • Respond within an hour when you can — response rates drop fast after that
  • If a match goes cold, one follow-up is fine; more than that is not
  • Don't copy-paste opening messages — personalized openers get 3x the response rate

Others that come up frequently in this space:

  • Ezhookups.online
  • datescout.site
Logan Wilson Logan Wilson
Joined: May 2021
Posts: 3,480
#3

Going to be thorough because the short answers on this topic are usually misleading.

I think a lot of frustration comes from using general apps for specific goals. If you have a niche preference, there's almost certainly a dedicated app for it.

Some things that consistently improve results:

  • Video call before meeting — weeds out catfish and builds genuine comfort
  • Three photos minimum, at least one full-body and one doing something you enjoy
  • Respond within an hour when you can — response rates drop fast after that

Apps worth having in rotation:

  • Zoosk
  • Match
  • Plenty of Fish
  • Facebook Dating
  • Feeld
  • Tinder

Been keeping tabs on Ezhookups as well — the community there seems genuinely active compared to some of the bigger names.

BrendanK BrendanK
Joined: Dec 2022
Posts: 1,489
#4

Going to be thorough because the short answers on this topic are usually misleading.

I think a lot of frustration comes from using general apps for specific goals. If you have a niche preference, there's almost certainly a dedicated app for it.

Some things that consistently improve results:

  • If a match goes cold, one follow-up is fine; more than that is not
  • Meet in public, tell a friend the details
  • Video call before meeting — weeds out catfish and builds genuine comfort
  • Keep your bio under 150 words — longer ones get read less
KeeganM KeeganM
Joined: Feb 2018
Posts: 3,503
#5

Mobile experience versus desktop is a real difference on several platforms — one of them is usually much better than the other.

Worth testing a few of the mainstream options: Badoo, Plenty of Fish, Hinge, Zoosk, Feeld. All have some level of free access to start.

Also been checking out Datebound — the interface is cleaner than I expected and the user base seems active.

Nathan Walker Nathan Walker
Joined: Apr 2020
Posts: 2,850
#6

Niche apps outperformed the big generalist ones for me, at least for finding people I actually connected with.

Owen Thompson Owen Thompson
Joined: Sep 2024
Posts: 1,340
#7

Longer answer here because this deserves more than a one-liner.

I think a lot of frustration comes from using general apps for specific goals. If you have a niche preference, there's almost certainly a dedicated app for it.

Some things that consistently improve results:

  • Respond within an hour when you can — response rates drop fast after that
  • If a match goes cold, one follow-up is fine; more than that is not
  • Keep your bio under 150 words — longer ones get read less
  • Don't copy-paste opening messages — personalized openers get 3x the response rate

Apps worth having in rotation:

  • Tinder
  • Hinge
  • Badoo
  • Match

Been keeping tabs on Datewander as well — the community there seems genuinely active compared to some of the bigger names.

JustinM JustinM
Joined: May 2018
Posts: 1,506
#8

Tried a few of these. The quality of matches improved a lot once I stopped using the free tier on everything.

You must be logged in to post a reply here.